Mexican Police Deliver Wrong Corpses to Get Murder Case Closed

By: Belén Marty - @belenmarty - Jul 9, 2015, 9:27 am
Relatives of the missing Mexican doctors claim Guerrero prosecutors tampered with evidence in a rush to close the case.
Relatives of the missing Mexican doctors claim Guerrero prosecutors tampered with evidence in a rush to close the case. (ADN Informativo)

EspañolThe families of four health-care workers, who went missing on June 19 in Guerrero, thought their ordeal was over when authorities handed over the victims’ corpses five days later.

Relatives claim, however, that the bodies are not their loved ones, and are now demanding that the lead prosecutor in the case step down and federal police take over the forensics examination.

Prior to their disappearance, doctors Marvin Hernández Ortega and Reynaldo Tepeque Cuevas, and administrative employees José Osvaldo Ortega Saucedo and Julio César Mejía Salgado, were traveling in a gray car that police later found in Xolapa, riddled with bullet holes, blood stains, and shells from a semi-automatic AR-15 rifle.

On Sunday, July 5, the victims’ families handed out leaflets, set up posters, and painted murals in Acapulco for the second consecutive day to urge authorities to keep searching for the missing medical professionals. Contrary to statements from Guerrero Attorney General Miguel Ángel Godínez Muñoz, their families do not believe they have yet been found.

“Respect life, missing doctors,” read one of the murals, while posters featured photographs of the four men and called upon the community to help with the search.

Further action was planned for Monday, July 6, as relatives moved to the offices of Mexico’s Attorney General in Guerrero, demanding the disclosure of the latest findings. They have also organized street protests and announced they will seek help from the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.

Wrong Corpses

During a press conference on June 24, the sister of Mejía Salgado said the bodies police found in the trunk of a Ford pick-up truck are not the missing doctors.

“How did we arrive at this conclusion? Because of their physical traits and what they were wearing,” she explained. She also criticized the media for confirming the physicians had been found before relatives had the chance to verify their identities.

Three days later, on June 27, prosecutors said in a press release that the bodies found matched those of the disappeared men based on a report by the Directorate of Forensic Services.

Cecilia Ortega Solórzano, mother of Hernández Ortega, disagrees with the report: “The day we were told about the bodies, we went to identify them, but they didn’t belong to our relatives, who have been missing for four days. These corpses were decaying as if they have been dead for 15 days,” she said.

On June 28, the families met with Governor Rogelio Ortega Martínez, who “does not believe the prosecutor … He is on our side, he believes us,” relatives told local reporters.

In a document delivered to the governor, they reject the forensic analysis and demand the prosecutor resign over his “ineptitude, lack of professionalism,” and “attempts to impose” his conclusions.

Guadalupe Reséndiz, a psychologist and wife of Tepeque, reported irregularities during the investigations. She says investigators tampered with the crime scene, and that the advanced decomposition of the corpses found suggests they died days before the physicians went missing.

Moreover, Reséndiz claims her husband height was around 1.74 meters tall, but the corpse authorities claim is him is between 1.82 and 1.85 meters tall. She says tattoos and other details on the body don’t match those of her husband either.

Prosecutors found shells from a semi-automatic AR-15 assault rifle inside the victims' vehicle.
Prosecutors found shells from a semi-automatic AR-15 assault rifle inside the victims’ vehicle. (Wikipedia)

Carlos Mejía Salgado, brother of Julio César, told press that the Prosecutor’s Office hastily removed investigators from where the remains were found, a move that showed “a tremendous lack of responsibility.” He suggests the prosecutor is rushing to close the investigation: “He wants to shelve the case.”

Salgado wants the federal police to run new DNA tests on the bodies. “We don’t anything they tell us here anymore; evidence can be manipulated,” he says.

“Meanwhile, the relatives of the missing doctors are weighing whether to join the parents of the 43 [students] and ‘The Other Disappeared’ of Iguala.”

In recent years, criminal gangs involved in drug trafficking, with ties to local politicians, have caused a surge in violence in the Mexican state of Guerrero. In June, a confrontation between armed vigilante groups left 16 dead.

In September 2014, Guerrero made headlines around the world after 43 student teachers from a rural school in Ayotzinapa were forcibly disappeared while traveling in Iguala.

Translated by Adam Dubove.

Belén Marty Belén Marty

Belén Marty is the Libertarian Latina, a journalist based in Buenos Aires, Argentina. She has lived in Guatemala, Jordan, the United Arab Emirates, and the United States and is a former candidate for local office with Argentina's Libertarian Party. Follow @BelenMarty.

Kuma: The Independent Who Defeated Mexico’s Political Machine

By: Franco Bastida - @iamtheFES - Jul 8, 2015, 3:58 pm
ft-pedro-numamoto-mexico

EspañolIn a country where politics is synonymous with corruption, elitism, and tradition, Pedro Kumamoto's rise is truly a David versus Goliath story. The world knows him as the 25-year-old who defeated Mexico's most powerful political parties with only US$1,100 (MEX$18,626) in state funding. One month since his historic victory on June 7, Pedro Kumamoto, the first independent congressman in the state of Jalisco, shares with the PanAm Post his experience during the campaign, as well as his expectations to create a more participatory democracy in Mexico. In the age of social media, Kuma, as he's known in the city of Zapopan, says candidates do not need party affiliations, big donors, or false promises to connect with citizens. Instead, they should seek to engage with the public and turn the system into a one that is more inclusive and community oriented. You studied Cultural Management at ITESO and were a founding member of the Wikipolítica democracy project. When did you realize you wanted to run for Congress? More than a specific moment or the interest to run for public office, what changed was my desire to get involved in the politics that lies within the government. We decided that we had to get involved in the decision-making process. This began since we started the Wikipolítica platform. It was a process in which the 17, 18 people who worked in the organization decided that that I should be the candidate, perhaps because of my role as president of the Student Association or as researcher at ITESO's Legislative Observatory. Given Mexico's recent political history, we decided to exercise our right to vote and be counted, and not just through traditional political parties but with an independent candidacy. You collected US$16,000 in donations and were heavily outspent. How did you come up with the motto, “Los muros sí caen” (Walls do fall)? I said the phrase during an interview. Afterwards, I tweeted it, and it went viral. We then realized that it was a worthwhile slogan. After consulting with some of our advisers, we realized that it could be a good motto to develop a really important concept for us: "political changes are born, forged, and conquered." https://twitter.com/pkumamoto/status/603394526405754880 "The walls of the political-party system will fall. The walls of despair will fall. Let's make history together." When the campaign kicked off, did you think the stark monetary and advertising difference between you and your opponents would be a disadvantage? No, on the contrary. In the end, those things do have their benefits, but we were really happy and convinced that we could run a different sort of campaign without an absurd amount of money. That freed us up to use our creativity as an asset. In other words, we did not have a lot of money, but we had a lot of people willing to dedicate their entire day to volunteering, thinking, and canvassing. That was an advantage over the political parties, whose supporters often will not show up and help unless you pay them. How did your team coin the narrative "citizens conversing with citizens" to generate a more democratic culture? Well, that was one of the most important aspects of Wikipolítica. We'd been working on that for two years. That's two years of theorizing, talking, and raising different issues. It was through these conversations that we came up with this narrative. It took many hours and lots of debate, but we think we came up with something solid in the end. Yours was a victory for social media and innovation over money. How did you capitalize on the hype and make sure it didn’t  stay online only? Actually, we hit the streets all the time. To put it one way, digital social networks mirror traditional, "analogue" social networks. It's utilizing, developing, and empowering trusted networks that are based on the principles, the ideas and the honesty that you can generate. Therefore, we were not a social-media movement. Although it is true that many people came to us thanks to our online outreach efforts, it is also true that we were not tweeting all day. I was on the ground, giving away stickers, at local markets, at universities. We went out and fought on both fronts. What you saw on social media was also happening on the streets, and vice versa. We believe in the power of social media, but we know that the power of face-to-face interactions will never be replaced. What was the key to winning the seat for Zapopan's 10th District? On the one hand, there's the utter discontent and rejection of traditional political parties by the people who live in my district. It's a deep-rooted rejection. My municipality historically votes for the opposition. On the other, we connected with experts and interest groups that provided us with legitimacy. To get there, we needed to have a creative campaign, one that aimed for innovation, not only in regards to technology but also on transparency and accountability, on generating a sense of belonging and establishing an inclusive platform. I think that the last component was the work of a great team, one that worked around 15 hours every day to win this seat. Based your experience, what would you say to other young adults across Latin America who, like your team, are also tired of the political party system in their own countries? I would tell them that they have every reason to be angry and to be tired of traditional politics, but I would continue with the same idea that we really want change. To reach our dreams, we need to get in the mix, and achieve them with our own hands. It's important that we make sure that no one, in any other future generation, has to fight for what our generation is fighting for today. There are two fronts. Perhaps one will be within the realm of traditional politics, and perhaps another outside of it. The key here is that we realize both are essential to achieve the society we are fighting for.

Weekly E-Newsletter

Get the latest from PanAm Post direct to your inbox!

We will never share your email with anyone.